The Ultimate Holiday Cookie Guide

November 28, 2016

The Ultimate Holiday Cookie Guide

We teamed up with Macaroni Kid this year to bring you a virtual Holiday Cookie Eggs-change.

After sorting through so many delicious recipes and wonderful family stories, we created The Ultimate Holiday Cookie Guide.

“Yule” be sure to impress guests by whipping up any of these delicious recipes below.

Light ‘n Fluffy Sugar Cookies from Micala B.


These are not just your average Christmas sugar cookies. The salty frosting and the sweet cookie are a unique combination that we couldn’t get enough of! They will melt in your mouth good and super light!

Coconut Chocolate Chip Cookie Bars from Desiree H.


A great option for a healthier cookie especially when made with Eggland’s Best eggs!

Chocolate Coconut Biscotti from Jenn P.


A super easy biscotti recipe packed with flavor and perfect for breakfast, snacks, or gift giving!

Gooey Butter Cookies from Crystal S.


These cookies are a descendant of Crystal’s heavenly Gooey Butter cake she made for family birthday parties. She perfected a cookie replica that’s the most decadent, melt-in-your mouth cookie you could ever dream of. Thanks for sharing it with us this holiday season!

Lemon Snickerdoodles from Sherry K.


Snickerdoodles minus the cinnamon? Don’t fret. These are so addictive that you may find yourself eating the whole batch in one day!

Gingerbread Cutout Cookies with Peppermint Icing from Carrie F.


These gingerbread cookies aren’t too sweet and are perfectly accompanied by peppermint icing. Split the dough up and use it for multiple batches or make a large batch to share with family and friends

Gluten-Free Peanut Butter Jelly Cookies  from Shatoya L.


For those of you who are Gluten free, there’s no need to sacrifice having delicious cookies this holiday season. Thanks to Shatoya these gluten free Peanut Butter & Jelly Cookies. They are the perfect combination for kids and adults alike!

Hot Chocolate Cup Cookies from Nicole M.


These cookies are almost too cute to eat…but not quite!  Not only are these Hot Chocolate Cup Cookies deliciously smooth on the inside with the perfect amount of crisp on the outside, but they’re guaranteed to standout at any get together. 

Holiday Eggnog Cookies from Amy M.


These cookies are packed with holiday flavor. Even if you don’t like eggnog, we beg you to give these cookies a try! We have no doubt that you’ll crave them long after the holidays are over!

Christmas Cherry Cookies from Joy G.


These Christmas Cherry Cookies are delicious and loaded with memories for Joy, whose grandma sent them in a Christmas package every year. We wish we got that package!

Holiday Cut-outs from Sarah D.


This Holiday Cookie recipe has been around for over 40 years! WOW! These cookies are so good that Sarah and her kids have been making them for other holidays by switching up the cookie cutters.

Dutch Delights from Christine P.


These Dutch Delights may take a tad extra love when preparing compared to simple cookies, but are the perfect complement to coffee, milk or even a cup of cocoa, especially if you’re a chocolate lover.

Are one of these cookies yours? Follow @egglandsbest on Instagram and tag yourself when you see your cookie in our Holiday Baking Spread from 12/12 – 12/22!

All recipes were recreated and photographed by Nathaniel from TermiNatetor Kitchen.